Hello dear
Welcome To The Gelato Fiasco Old Port
At The Gelato Fiasco Old Port, located in the heart of Portland, ME, gelato is a passion. This quaint gelateria is dedicated to crafting exceptional flavors, from classic Strawberry Balsamic to creative delights like Carrot Cake. With a commitment to inclusivity, they offer vegan and dairy-free options alongside a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Guests can enjoy their treats at outdoor seating or take them home in pints, perfect for any occasion. The friendly staff encourages sampling before settling on favorites, ensuring a personalized experience. It’s more than just gelato; it’s a delightful escape filled with flavor and community spirit.
About
The Gelato Fiasco Old Port
Welcome to The Gelato Fiasco Old Port, a delightful haven nestled in the heart of Portland, Maine, at 425 Fore Street. This charming spot is more than just a gelato shop; it’s a vibrant destination where each scoop tells a story. With an inviting atmosphere and a commitment to quality, The Gelato Fiasco Old Port stands out as a must-visit for both locals and travelers alike.
The Gelato Fiasco is renowned for its extensive menu, offering a range of creamy gelato and refreshing sorbetto options. Imagine savoring a pint filled with your choice of flavors—up to three per container! Whether you're drawn in by the Strawberry Balsamic or the intriguing Apple Cider and Donuts, there's a flavor to satisfy every palate. The careful craftsmanship behind their gelato creates a taste experience that leaves you longing for more.
Among the highlights, the Muddy Bites Snack Pack features delightful mini waffle cones filled with rich chocolate—perfect for a tasty treat on the go. For those looking to quench their thirst, the selection includes refreshing Italian soda, a perfect complement to your gelato choices.
Not only does The Gelato Fiasco Old Port prioritize great flavor, but it also caters to a variety of dietary preferences. With vegan and dairy-free options available, everyone can indulge in delicious gelato without worrying about allergens. Reviewing from customers speaks volumes; visitors like Kristopher M. have praised the welcoming and friendly staff, while Tiffany V. highlights the opportunity to sample flavors before making a choice—a testament to their dedication to customer satisfaction.
The atmosphere combines an eclectic mix of decor, lending a unique feel to your gelato enjoyment. Although the decor might raise eyebrows, it adds character to the small yet cozy seating area—perfect for enjoying your gelato with friends or family. With outdoor seating available, it’s a fantastic spot to soak up the Portland air while indulging in a sweet treat. Moreover, the establishment is equipped to handle modern conveniences with services like delivery, takeout, and multiple payment options, ensuring a seamless experience.
In summary, The Gelato Fiasco Old Port stands out not only for its mouthwatering gelato but also for its warm atmosphere and customer-centric service. It’s a place where you can unwind, share laughter, and indulge in flavors that spark joy. So next time you’re in town, be sure to stop by and enjoy a scoop or two—your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Manager was super welcoming and friendly and the gelato is always to die for! I overheard a customer with a peanut allergy very satisfied as well. Chill, clean vibe. ”
“ A must try if you are in Portland! The staff are very nice about letting you try a bunch of flavors before you settle on your favorites! Highly recommend getting a couple pints to take home with you, it was great having a freezer stash this holiday season! Some of the ones we tried and would recommend: Strawberry Balsamic Sweet Resergam Apple Cider and Donuts Cardamom Carrot Cake Banana Pudding ”
“ Small, no-frills, gelato spot in downtown Portland with a comprehensive selection of delicious gelato flavors The also have coffee and a cookie that they price "at market value", which is hilarious, but I only tried the gelato A few tables for seating, but not a ton ”
“ great gelato and friendly staff! i appreciate that they're open late. i will say, the atmosphere is so strange. i'm not sure who is in charge of their decor but it's a weird mix of japanese art, wood paneling, and fake crown molding. it's rather strange for a brand new building. also their cookie is subject to "market" price?? that's so funny ”
“ Some of the best gelato I've ever had. Luckily this spot was right near our Airbnb so we could go multiple times while we were in town. They have tons of great flavors. Everything was fresh and the flavor was amazing. The first time we went I had the mint chip and cake batter. The second time I had the strawberry and oreo cookies. Both were amazing! I love getting a combo of flavors. I got a size small and they really filled up the cup. It was plenty for my husband and I to split. They have plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. Great vibe and friendly staff. Highly recommend! ”
“ I love this icecream spot! Usually I don't really eat gelato but this place hits the spot especially the strawberry balsamic flavor. Also, the staff that was taking my order was so sweet and accommodating which made my experience even better. Definitely recommend this local icecream spot when you come to Portland, Maine ”
“ We stopped in after dinner next door. The gelato was not mounded in the tubs, which was a good sign. I went for the sorbetto options, as regular dairy doesn't get along with me. I sampled the almond and the raspberry truffle. Both were tasty, but the almond was so full of toasted almond goodness that I had to get it. No regrets whatsoever. ”
“ Shortly before my most recent trip to Portland, one of my friends and I were sharing spots to check out as she had a trip planned up here too. One place she had recommended that wasn't on my radar was The Gelato Fiasco. I've been to another gelato spot in Portland, but I thought it would be a good idea to spice it up a bit a check this spot out - so that's what I did. GF is located on Fore Street in pretty much the heart of Old Port. The outside doesn't have the charm of some other spots in the vicinity, but I think it's due to the fact that the spot is contiguous with a hotel that has its own aesthetics. There was a short line when I walked in, which was fine since it gave me a chance to check out the menu. They have several flavors to choose from, as well as a decent array of sorbet. I decided on a cup, and I was told I can choose as many flavors as I wanted no matter what size - wow. I didn't want to go too nuts so I went with two: fresh cream and Maine wild blueberry crunch. The gelato was great - super creamy with great flavor; for some reason I was expecting something mid but it really exceeded them. Service was friendly - they were handling a large group in front of me but they did a great job maintaining traffic flow and excellent customer service. Overall, this is a yes - definitely worth a stop while in Portland. ”
“ One of the best gelatos I've eaten in America. Proper Italian gelato not to be confused with ice cream. Ice cream does not deserve the label of gelato. The flavors run from the classic (salted caramel, dark chocolate) to the seasonal (wild Maine blueberry crisp) to the gourmet (mascarpone, lavender) to the candy bar-stuffed (peanut butter with m&ms and Oreos). The quality is exceptional: voluptuous texture and intense flavor that doesn't dull on your tastebuds over time. I will be here every day during my stay in Portland. ”
“ Pros: -Service here was excellent! Such a friendly staff member -Can try as many as you want AND can combine multiple flavors into any size that you want. It's so refreshing to not have limits that most shops have on these -Hazelnut was absolutely delicious! Would love to return to try some of the other appetizing sounding flavors! ”
